How to Choose a Plan?

Key Points

  • There are two main Medicare coverage options: Medicare Supplement (Medigap) plans and Medicare Advantage plans, each functioning differently.

  • Because Medigap plans are standardized, it’s wise to compare insurance carriers based on their rate increase history and financial strength when choosing a plan.

  • Medicare Advantage plans vary by type—such as HMO or PPO—so it’s important to evaluate which plan type best fits your healthcare needs and preferences.

We'll Find The Right Plan for YOU for FREE

We understand Medicare, so you don't have to

If you’re feeling overwhelmed trying to choose a Medicare plan, you’re not alone.

Many people tell us they considered themselves fairly savvy—until they started navigating Medicare. It’s a common experience.

But don’t worry—Medicare can be confusing, and that’s exactly why we’re here to help. You don’t have to figure it out on your own.

Selecting the Right Type of Medicare Plan

As you begin your search for Medicare Supplement insurance, there are several key factors to consider.

First, understand the difference between the two main types of Medicare plans: Medicare Supplement (Medigap) and Medicare Advantage (Part C). These plans operate differently and offer distinct approaches to coverage.

Once you’re familiar with how each plan works, ask yourself the following questions to help determine which option best fits your needs:

1. Do your primary doctors participate in any Medicare Advantage networks, or do they only accept Original Medicare?

2. What insurance is accepted by the hospitals you prefer?

3. Do you travel frequently? If so, Original Medicare with a Medigap plan may be more suitable, as it’s accepted by any doctor or hospital nationwide that takes Medicare.

4. What is your risk tolerance? If you face high medical expenses in a given year, do you have the savings to cover the out-of-pocket maximum under a Medicare Advantage plan?

5. What gives you peace of mind? If you’re comfortable with lower premiums and paying for services as needed, a Medicare Advantage plan may be a good fit. However, if you prefer predictable costs and less worry about unexpected bills, a Medigap plan might offer more financial security.

Taking the time to reflect on these questions can help you make a more confident and informed Medicare decision.

Valuable Advice from Our Specialists

At Side By Side Insurance Solutions, we provide a variety of resources to help you make informed Medicare decisions.

First, you can register for a free Medicare review call. Led by our agency founder, Carmen Scarcelli, these sessions break down the fundamentals of Medicare in clear, easy-to-understand language. The webinars last about an hour and include a Q&A session so you can get personalized answers—all from the comfort of your home or office.

Next, explore our blog post comparing Medicare Advantage and Medicare Supplement (Medigap) plans. We’ve also created a downloadable guide to help you evaluate which option aligns best with your healthcare needs. If you’re a snowbird or frequent traveler, be sure to check out our dedicated article on how seasonal living can affect your Medicare coverage.

Once you’ve identified the right path, you can move forward with obtaining quotes from top insurance carriers tailored to your chosen coverage.

Selecting the Right Medicare Supplement Plan

In 1990, the government standardized Medicare Supplement (Medigap) plans to make it easier for beneficiaries to compare options. You can view a Medigap plan comparison chart right here on our website, outlining the benefits of Plans A through N.

If you decide a Medigap plan is the right fit for your needs, our team at Senior Solutions can provide a customized list of plans available in your area. As a leading Medicare insurance broker, we use advanced quoting tools to show real-time pricing for all available plans nationwide.

Medicare Supplement premiums are influenced by several factors, including your age, gender, ZIP code, tobacco use, and household discount eligibility. Additionally, state-specific regulations may also affect your premium.

At Senior Solutions, we go a step further by identifying the top three most competitively priced carriers for your chosen plan and reviewing their historical rate increases. While future rate changes can’t be guaranteed, this data helps us guide you toward a well-informed, cost-effective decision.

Selecting the Right Medicare Advantage Plan

If you’re leaning toward a Medicare Advantage plan, we use the official Medicare Plan Finder Tool at www.medicare.gov to explore plan options available in your county, based on your healthcare preferences and needs.

Some individuals choose Medicare HMO plans for their lower premiums, while others prefer Medicare PPO plans for the added flexibility and out-of-network access. In certain areas, you may also find alternative plan types, such as Medicare Cost Plans, Special Needs Plans (SNPs), or Private Fee-for-Service (PFFS) plans.

Our knowledgeable agents are experienced with all plan types and can help you navigate the options, ensuring you find a plan that aligns with your doctors and healthcare priorities.

Key Takeaways

  • Ultimately, choosing the right Medicare plan depends on several factors, including your budget, health status, lifestyle, and personal preferences.

  • Medigap plans are often ideal for individuals who have ongoing health conditions, visit the doctor frequently, or want comprehensive coverage for unexpected medical needs.

  • On the other hand, Medicare Advantage plans may be a better fit for those who are generally healthy and willing to pay out-of-pocket costs as they arise, in exchange for a lower monthly premium.

Side By Side Insurance Solutions - Get FREE Assistance

If Medicare feels confusing, you don’t have to figure it out alone. Our friendly, knowledgeable agents are here to guide you every step of the way—making the process simple and stress-free.


We start with the basics, helping you understand your Original Medicare coverage. This foundation is key to finding the supplemental plan that fits your needs, especially if you’re new to Medicare.

Once your policy is in place, you’ll have peace of mind knowing we’re just a phone call away whenever you need help or have questions.

Best of all—our services are completely free. Experience the difference of having Side By Side Insurance Solutions on your side. Call (863) 450-1777 or click the button below to get started:

Get In Touch

Side By Side Insurance Solutions

Lakeland, Florida

(863) 450-1777

​Email Us: [email protected]

Copyright 2025. All Right are Reserved. Side By SIde Insurance Solutions